2.1.0rc: conversion to mp3 (via gui) does not allow changing of the output file extension (from .raw)

the extension should probably be stored in the conversion profile (not hardcoded per encapsulation)

and it should be possible to change it in the destination file field

added Severity::normal Type::bug Version::master git + 1 deleted label

changed milestone to %Bugs paradize

assigned to @jbk and unassigned @MigrationBot

added Component::Interface: Qt label and removed 1 deleted label

What ? http://git.videolan.org/?p=vlc/vlc-2.1.git;a=commit;h=0e7d446bf01de2ac385092120979e3c475ccfc3f

assigned to @fcartegnie and unassigned @jbk

Extensions is enforced to mux format, which profile has been previously fixed

added Status::fixed label

closed

are you claiming it's fixed in rc1?

it's not, raw is forced when using the mp3 profile(perhaps modified) or new custom profile.

don't force the extension, raw is hardly ever what's needed

Original author: laxeraend

Don't try rc1. Always try nightlies.

If you use a custom profile, it forces the raw extension for raw encapsulation. Why override the user choice of extension?

Original author: laxeraend

removed Status::fixed label

reopened

changed milestone to %2.1.x maintenance bugs

it's not a "raw" problem, it just doesn't load the custom profile when you create it. Profile is correctly saved, and selecting profile is also correct.

it's not a "raw" problem

I don't know what that means, the problem is very simple, the ui does not let you change the extension. So whatever default you pick, let the user change it.

Original author: laxeraend

It does. Give your version & test case or I close this bug.

Replying to [comment:11 fcartegnie]:

It does.

does what?

Give your version & test case or I close this bug.

rc2 windows

convert an mp4 file via gui, create a new profile wih raw encapsulation, no video, mp3 audio

it forces .raw extension, if you change it in the edit box, it will change back when the conversion starts

Original author: laxeraend

closed

commit 82d7c41a Author: Francois Cartegnie fcvlcdev@free.fr Date: Thu Sep 12 23:59:34 2013 +0200

Qt: convert: don't enforce container extension (fix [#9282](https://code.videolan.org/videolan/vlc/-/issues/9282))

added Status::fixed label

Extensions in profiles is another problem and is more complex.

Vorbis + (0..n tracks)-> ogg, ogm, ogv, ...

Needs another ticket.

changed milestone to %2.1.0 release

this is not fixed in 2.1.0

when converting with a custom profile, if you change the extension in the "destination file" edit box from .raw to .mp3, it reverts to .raw when the edit box loses focus

Original author: laxeraend

removed Status::fixed label

reopened

added Status::fixed label

closed

changed milestone to %2.1.x maintenance bugs

mentioned in issue #10801 (closed)