Graphical glitches for bluray videos with hardware decoding on windows 10 x64 creators update 1709

Blu Ray videos are incorrect shown on Windows 10 x64 - this is independant of the vlc version ( tested official vlc-3.0.0 and nightly update of vlc-4.0.0 )

There is no problem on the same computer when running Linux ( fedora 27 with vlc-3.0.0 or openSUSE 42.3 with vlc-4.0.0 )

The PC is a Fujitsu Esprimo P900 with Intel Core i5-2400 and Intel HD Graphics 2000.

log for vlc-3.0.0 on windows

Added attachment:

• vlc-3.0.0-graphic-presentation-error-windows-10-x64-creators-update-1709.log.gz

log for vlc-4.0.0 on windows

Added attachment:

• vlc-4.0.0-graphic-presentation-error-windows-10-x64-creators-update-1709.log.gz

graphical presentation error of blu ray video on windows

Added attachment:

• vlcsnap-2018-02-27-12h14m35s425.jpg

log for the same blu ray video on fedora

Added attachment:

• vlc-3.0.0-fedora-27.log.gz

log for the same blu ray video on openSUSE

Added attachment:

• vlc-4.0.0-openSUSE-42.3.log.gz

Does it work without hardware decoding?

The hardware decoding was for Windows and Linux "automatic". The problem for windows 10 does not exist for hardware decoding disabled.

changed title from graphical presentation errors for blu ray videos on windows 10 x64 creators update 1709 to Graphical glitches for bluray videos with hardware decoding on windows 10 x64 creators update 1709

Hmm, That's weird.

Any test with 3.0.2?

assigned to @robUx4

added Component::Video: Direct3D / Win32 label

Problem is still not solved with last 3.0.2 or 4.0.0

error exists also for other videoformats like mkv

changed milestone to %3.0.x maintenance

Please try a more recent nightly build

same problem with actual version of 3.0.2

Added attachment:

• vlc-3.0.2-graphic-presentation-error-windows-10-x64-creators-update-1709.log

same problem with actual version of 4.0.0

Added attachment:

• vlc-4.0.0-graphic-presentation-error-windows-10-x64-creators-update-1709.log

the problem was reproduced with the latest nightly updates of v3.0.2 / v4.0.0 for mkv-video.format

Nothing weird in the logs.

However, are your logs with your i5 ?

Logs from my PC (HWiNFO64)

Added attachment:

• P900.LOG

However, are your logs with your i5 ? YES - for details please see attached log from HWiNFO64

Can you share the files you are using ? Maybe they are damaged.

Also test the same files on both platforms for a better comparison.

log for mkv video with actual vlc-3.0.2-dgb (Hardware accelerated decoding set to automatic)

Added attachment:

• vlc-3.0.2-graphic-presentation-error-windows-10-x64-creators-update-1709-gdb.zip

log for mkv video with actual vlc-4.0.0-dgb (Hardware accelerated decoding set to automatic)

Added attachment:

• vlc-4.0.0-graphic-presentation-error-windows-10-x64-creators-update-1709-gdb.zip

To reproduce the error you can use the video stored on my googledrive https://drive.google.com/file/d/1xzIP9W1Ip1yFS0MXqoFD94oVkdKuw0FG/view?usp=sharing

Preferences in Input/Codecs are set to automatic

I don't think that you can compare the vlc windows version with the vlc version 4.0.0 on openSUSE Leap 42.3.

The systems have different graphic drivers and the available options for Preferences -> Input/Codes -> Hardware accelerated decoding are for Windows and openSUSE different

on Windows you can select from :\ Automatic\ Direct3D11 Video Acceleration\ DirectX Video Acceleration (DXVA) 2.0\ Disable

on openSUSE you have\ Automatic\ VA-API Video decoding\ VDPAU Video decoding\ VA-API Video decoding via DRM\ disable

Alternate from my video on my google drive you can also download a video from http://serienjunkies.org/serie/designated-survivor/ e.g. Designated.Survivor.S02E15.Summit.German.Synced.DL.AmazonHD.x264-TVS to unrar the file you need the password serienjunkies.org

or you can download the file from USENET : https://nzbindex.nl/search/?q=58xp088AH5fqNyp8eQEMyFRyl1O7nQ&age=100&max=250&minage=&sort=agedesc&minsize=100&maxsize=&dq=&poster=&hidespam=0&hidespam=1&more=1 \

NZB Name fuer SabNZB & Newsleecher:\

Designated.Survivor.S02E15.Summit.German.Synced.DL.AmazonHD.x264-TVS{{58csjk0t3hpOtKA0T5In}}

It's an old Intel GPU so it doesn't work in D3D11, it fallbacks to D3D9 support. But it should work anyway. For D3D11 support you may force DIRECT3D11 as the video output and D3D11VA for the video decoder. It may help.

Other than that it's using the Intel ClearVideo H.264 decoder instead of the regular one that is also available. I changed the priority between these 2 decoders. We'll see if it helps. You will be able to try it in the nightlies built tonight (so available tomorrow).

(in the 4.0 nightly for now, if it helps we'll backport to 3.0.2 as well)

You have fixed this problem on the actual nightly release of vlc-4.0.0 Thank you.

See 3fe46b99 and BP.

added Status::fixed label

changed milestone to %3.0.2

closed

Backported as d0a16b80cbd0b38417258086f25f3e522ee9e896